Philosophy as engagement for rationality

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Despite the apparent ample justification for teaching children to be rational, there is considerable controversy among philosophers over whether rationality is worth defending as a basic educational ideal. For instance, while some critical theorists assert that the extraordinary success of reason, in the form of scientific rationality and means/end calculations, in offering mankind domination over nature leads inexorably to domination of humans over humans, many feminist philosophers argue against rationality on the grounds that our traditional ideals of rationality are often modelled on stereotypically masculine traits (e.g. being dispassionate) and then used to denigrate the stereotyped nature of women (e.g. being emotional). In this paper, I first argue that, following Nicholas Rescher, rationality should be conceptualized as comprising cognitive, practical, and evaluative rationality. For one thing, this conception is comprehensive and thus able to remedy the defects of the popular means end theory. For another, the ideal of rationality implicit in this conception is an Inclusive rather than an exclusive one: not only does it not force us to choose between the cognitive and emotional components of our nature, it actually forbids nothing that is good for us. Based on this tripartite conception of rationality, I then advance an argument founded on pragmatic considerations for rationality as a fundamental educational ideal. Finally, in order to promote the development of rationality in children, I suggest that teachers should engage them in doing philosophy in the classroom, especially by means of Matthew Lipman’s Philosophy for Children programme.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2014

Fingerprint

Philosophy
Rationality
Ideal
Conception
Emotion
Domination
Education
Philosopher
Justification
Masculine
Defects
Mankind
Theorists
Teaching
Philosophy for children
Nicholas Rescher
Scientific Rationalism
Nature
Fundamental

Citation

Lam, C.-M. (2014, November). Philosophy as engagement for rationality . Paper presented at the 44th the Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia (PESA) Annual Conference, Kingsgate Hotel, New Zealand.