Mosston's reciprocal style of teaching: A pilot study in Hong Kong

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Mosston’s “spectrum of teaching styles” which composes of 11 pedagogical approaches in physical education (PE), has been popularly promoted for maximizing students’ learning in the Western countries. However, very few of them have been put into practice and studied in Hong Kong. This article concerned a report of a pilot study on one of the teaching styles, reciprocal teaching. Aims: The study aimed to examine students’ and teacher’s experiences when engaging in learning and teaching in reciprocal teaching. Sample: 3 classes of 80 male students (Form 3 : 31 students, Form 2 : 26 & Form 1 : 23)from a local secondary school and their PE teacher were invited to participate in the study. Methods: Attached to the action research perspective, 3 teaching units of gymnastics, swimming and handball were conducted in the form of reciprocal teaching. Data composed of students’ reflective journals and interviewas well as teacher’s self review were collected at the end of the teaching units. Findings: both the teacher and students experienced reciprocal teaching positively. Students perceived their learning as active and comfortable. They were satisfied with their mastery of skills, taking peer tutoring roles, engaging in observing, taking care of others and seeing their partner’s improvement. They also encountered with those dissatisfying experiences of boring, simple and repetitive learning content, difficult skills and the undesirable learning attitude of some of the students that they feared of ending up with discipline problems and learning nothing. Their articulation with their improvement in collaboration, communication and presentation skills, building up confidence, team spirit and learning attitude of trying hard was found. Conclusion: The reciprocal teaching might solve some of the current PE problems of passive learning, little collaboration and weak accountability of learning as well as empowering students in their learning. Students’ worries concerning reciprocal teaching might end up with learning nothing. Their worries may generate pedagogical implications on how reciprocal teaching can be implemented fully. It is suggested to launch large scale studies relating to the application of reciprocal teaching on different levels of students and other PE teaching contents. Copyright © 2011 New Horizons in Education.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)27-37
JournalNew Horizons in Education
Volume59
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2011

Fingerprint

Hong Kong
Teaching
learning
student
physical education
teaching unit
teaching style
teacher
teaching content
action research
secondary school
experience
confidence
responsibility
communication

Citation

Li, C., & Kam, W. K. (2011). Mosston's reciprocal style of teaching: A pilot study in Hong Kong. New Horizons in Education, 59(2), 27-37.

Keywords

  • Peer-assisted learning
  • Innovation
  • Teaching styles
  • Mosston之互惠式教學法:香港的一項先導研究